Comfortable stay with free Wi-Fi, kitchen, and airport shuttle near Perry's Victory Memorial and South Bass Island. Rated 4.4 from 76 reviews.
Highly regarded for its cleanliness, spacious accommodations, and friendly staff, this property offers a relaxing stay close to Put-in-Bay's main attractions with convenient amenities for groups and families alike.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Island Club Rentals offers a collection of vacation home rentals and hotel accommodations nestled in Put-In-Bay, Ohio. The property scores a solid 4.4 out of 5 based on 76 reviews, highlighting a clean, comfortable, and relaxed atmosphere suitable for families, groups, and pet owners alike. The setting combines proximity to the main attractions with a quieter neighborhood vibe, appealing to visitors seeking both convenience and calm.
Each rental features practical amenities such as air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, and fully equipped kitchens, making longer stays comfortable and flexible. The property is pet-friendly and kid-friendly, with additional services including airport shuttle and access to a nearby golf course. Guests appreciate the ease of booking and find the properties well-maintained, with spacious layouts that accommodate families and groups.
Located at 1609 Leeward Lane, Island Club Rentals sits near popular Put-In-Bay destinations like Perry's Victory & International Peace Memorial and South Bass Island State Park, both within easy reach. The proximity to local ferry services and airports like Cleveland Hopkins International (about 1 hour 50 minutes by car) adds to the convenience for travelers.
Reviews often mention helpful and friendly staff, easy access to golf cart rentals, and a neighborhood that balances the liveliness of nearby events with peaceful surroundings. While the property suits those looking to explore sightseeing and recreational opportunities, it also accommodates guests seeking a relaxing retreat after a day of island activities.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
I had a wonderful stay at Island Club Rentals! The place was clean, comfortable, and very relaxing. The staff was friendly and helpful, and the location was perfect. I’d definitely love to come back!
Had an incredible time at Island Club Rentals with friends! The house was clean, spacious, and had a great setup for a group. The location was perfect—close to all the fun spots on the island but still peaceful when we wanted to relax. The staff was very accommodating and made everything easy for us. Definitely a top choice for a Put-in-Bay getaway!
This was my first time here and I had an awesome trip! The staff was very friendly and the place was nice. I can’t wait to come back and wouldn’t change anything!
Our house was a perfect fit for the four of us. We had 4 adults and a dog with us and there was plenty of room for us. You can rent golf carts directly from the club, which makes for super easy pickup and dropoff. Very affordable.
I stayed at House 102 for the weekend and had a wonderful experience! The house was very clean, and the kitchen has been beautifully redone—it’s modern, spacious, and a joy to cook in. Booking was super easy on their website, and the prices were very reasonable. Everything felt welcoming and well-maintained. I would definitely stay here again!
Funny I’ve been going to PIB for 20 years and never even knew about the island club. It’s pretty close to the Miller Ferry, airport etc and has a pretty cool neighborhood vibe. We stayed in cabin 93 and it was excellent and clean: we brought our own pillows and blankets but there were some there. Lots of bathrooms and beds, everything worked great. A couple bachelorette parties and younger crowd on the night of bash at the bay but me and my 5 year old were able to get to bed early no problem. I showed up after hours for golf cart and they still took care of me. Will be back again. Pool was great too!
I had such a great experience staying at Island Club Rentals in Put-in-Bay! The property was clean, spacious, and had everything we needed for a comfortable getaway. The location was perfect – close enough to downtown and the main attractions, but still tucked away so we could relax and enjoy some peace and quiet. Whether you’re visiting with friends, family, or a group, Island Club Rentals is a fantastic place to stay. I’d definitely come back and recommend it to anyone looking for a fun and relaxing Put-in-Bay trip!
I had a wonderful stay at these cabins! The place is cozy, clean, and surrounded by beautiful nature, making it the perfect spot to relax and disconnect. The cabin was well-equipped with everything we needed, and the beds were very comfortable. The staff was friendly and attentive, always making sure we felt welcome.
Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Ohio. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
3,028 reviews 93 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456, United States
79 reviews Put-in-Bay Township, OH 43456, USA
1,501 reviews 1523 Catawba Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Enjoy a 4.8rated stay at Yellow Rose Inn in Nazareth, TX. Amenities include free WiFi and parking. Ideal for sightseeing and con...
SanRan Motel offers airconditioned rooms with coffeemakers, minifridges, and microwaves in Robbinsville, NC. Enjoy petfriendly,...
Relax at The Watson Hotel in Midtown NYC featuring a seasonal rooftop pool, gym, restaurant, and easy access to Times Square and M...
Conway Express Inn offers free WiFi and parking in Conway, SC. Near Myrtle Beach and local attractions, ideal for sightseeing and...
Charming hotel in Bar Harbor offering free WiFi, breakfast, parking, and harbor views. Near Acadia National Park, Cadillac Mounta...
Stay at Best Western Lone Star Inn in Edna, TX. Enjoy free breakfast, WiFi, parking, outdoor pool, and hot tub near Lake Texana a...
Relax at Pointes North Beachfront Resort Hotel with private beach, outdoor pool, free WiFi, and a prime Traverse City location ne...
Basic budget hotel in Selma, AL offering straightforward rooms, some with kitchenettes, free breakfast, pet and kidfriendly, nea...
Relax at Microtel Inn & Suites by Wyndham Harrisonburg with free breakfast, WiFi, parking, and an outdoor pool. Near James Madiso...
Upscale hotel in a landmark building with relaxed rooms, sleek dining, and LGBTQ+ friendly amenities near theaters, Target Center,...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
